Nathan Fielder’s latest documentary film is drawing early reviews, and critics say its focus caught them off guard. You Can See Everything premiered at the Telluride Film Festival and received a positive response.
Directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, the documentary follows notorious Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes before her prison sentence. It centers on Holmes and her family as the filmmakers gain unusual access to their lives. However, reviews suggest the documentary gradually shifts toward her husband, Billy Evans, and the increasingly uneasy dynamic surrounding their relationship.
Billy Evans becomes the film’s most unsettling presence
Indie Wire’s review emphasizes that Holmes’ husband, Billy Evans, becomes an overbearing force inside the documentary. It describes a scene where Evans grabs a whisk from Holmes mid-task, insisting on doing it the “right way” himself. When Fielder questions his action directly, Evans dismisses it as simply wanting to help.
From there, the review says Evans becomes harder to look away from. As Holmes and Evans pull Fielder into their conversations, the camera increasingly turns toward him too, blurring the line between filmmaker and subject. That puts audiences in the same position as the director, left to piece together the truth as it gets buried under the couple’s own manipulation.
The Telluride premiere garnered rave reviews from the critics. @nrdgrn called You Can See Everything “easily the best film of the year,” adding that it develops into something “structurally, stylistically, and formally even more shocking.”
@howatdk similarly described it as a “hysterical, shocking, insane documentary.” The reviewer praised its exploration of Holmes, truth, and deception, particularly with Fielder embedded inside the family.
Perhaps the strongest indication of the documentary’s unusual nature came from Fielder himself. According to @ThatRebecca, he admitted, “I’m struggling to this day to understand exactly what I experienced,” during a Q&A session at the film’s premiere venue.
A24 has announced it is set to hit theaters in October, but the exact release date is unknown.
