Billy Evans responded to Amanda Seyfried after the actress criticized his behavior in the documentary You Can See Everything. Evans pushed back against her interpretation of his relationship with Elizabeth Holmes and questioned how much she knew about their life together.
The 34-year-old addressed Seyfried’s remarks in an interview with The Hollywood Reporter. He also discussed his portrayal in the documentary, which follows his life with Holmes during the 34 days before she began her prison sentence in May 2023.
Billy Evans pushes back against Amanda Seyfried’s portrayal of his marriage
Seyfried, who portrayed Holmes in The Dropout, previously told Rolling Stone that footage from You Can See Everything had given her a negative impression of Evans. She said her opinion of him only worsened after meeting him during filming.
In his interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Evans questioned Seyfried’s assessment and suggested that her experience portraying Holmes may have influenced how she interpreted their relationship.
He also argued that Seyfried had never spent time with him and Holmes as a couple. According to Evans, the actress formed her opinions based on edited footage rather than witnessing their relationship firsthand.
The documentary featured a tense dinner involving Seyfried and Evans. Looking back on the interaction, Evans suggested that he better understood her intentions. He pointed to a moment when Seyfried expressed her desire to separate him from Holmes.
Evans also disputed suggestions that he controlled Holmes through power of attorney. He explained that her incarceration meant he had to handle certain financial and legal responsibilities while raising their two children.
The interview also addressed the documentary’s portrayal of Evans helping Holmes prepare eggs. He rejected interpretations that connected his involvement in cooking to controlling behavior.
Evans explained that Holmes had spent years managing Theranos and rarely cooked. He added that he enjoyed preparing meals and had taken on cooking responsibilities during her pregnancies.
Despite his objections to aspects of the film, Evans praised filmmakers Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim for their work. However, he maintained that parts of the documentary did not reflect his experiences.
Evans also defended his relationship with Holmes, saying that he remained happy with their life together despite the public criticism.
