The Season 1 finale of The Traitors: New Blood saw Shane Beatty emerge as the show’s sole winner, taking home $246,000. However, Abbey Benjamin and Wyatt Gillespie were left shocked by his betrayal.
Abbey Benjamin and Wyatt Gillespie were blindsided by Shane Beatty’s betrayal
Beatty’s victory marked a first for the series. The 32-year-old ironworker became the first recruited Traitor to win. He reached the final alongside Benjamin, a 37-year-old nurse from Louisiana. Gillespie, a 26-year-old designer from Pennsylvania, also made it to the final.
The Faithfuls had no idea Beatty was a recruited Traitor. Benjamin and Gillespie believed they would share the prize money equally. However, their excitement turned to shock when host Alan Cumming asked them to reveal their final roles. Beatty broke down in tears before admitting he had been playing as a Traitor.
Speaking to Entertainment Weekly, Benjamin and Gillespie recalled their reactions to Beatty’s betrayal.
Gillespie said, “I was completely and utterly blindsided. I mean, at no point in time did I even know an ultimatum was happening. And we had even talked before Shane was even at the ultimatum about, like, ‘Man, it’s so late in the show. I wonder if there’s a recruitment that’s gonna happen or if there’s an ultimatum that’s gonna happen.’ And it wasn’t even a possibility in my head.”
Benjamin said, “I felt like somebody had written me about an $80,000 check, and as they were handing it to me just, like, ripped it up. And that’s a lot of money to have taken right out from under you. So I would say shock and just absolute heartbreak.”
The Traitors: New Blood wrapped up its first season on November 19. The competition brought 22 civilian contestants to the Scottish Highlands. However, the franchise isn’t done yet. The Traitors will return with an all-celebrity cast on January 14, 2027. Reality TV personalities Bronwyn Newport and Whitney Leavitt will be among the contestants.
