Practical Magic 2 is off to a rough start with critics. The long-awaited sequel reunites Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman as sisters Sally and Gillian Owens. The two stars return nearly three decades after the original film became a cult favorite.
The sequel currently holds a 32% score on Rotten Tomatoes, making it Bullock’s worst-reviewed film in almost 20 years. Directed by Susanne Bier, the sequel arrives nearly 30 years after the original Practical Magic. It brings the Owens sisters back for another supernatural adventure as their family faces a new threat. It is scheduled to hit theaters on September 10, 2026.
The original Practical Magic was not a critical success when it opened in 1998. It currently has a 30% score on Rotten Tomatoes. Despite its poor reviews, the film developed a dedicated following over the years. Its themes of sisterhood and magic, along with Bullock and Kidman’s performances, helped it remain popular with audiences.
What do the Practical Magic 2 reviews say?
Practical Magic 2 received mixed reactions from the critics. Several reviews praise Bullock and Kidman for their chemistry and screen presence. However, reviews have also raised concerns about the screenplay, pacing, tone, and reliance on nostalgia.
The Guardian gave the film three out of five stars. Its review praised the returning stars and the film’s focus on sisterhood and feminine resilience. However, it also described the revival as “obligatory” and pointed to some underused supporting characters.
Variety called the sequel an “overlong, predictable” follow-up that fails to recapture the original’s appeal. Critic Todd Gilchrist argued that the 130-minute runtime makes the film feel drawn out. The review also criticized the sequel for repeating the same elements without fixing the weaknesses that affected the first film.
The Independent critic Clarice Loughrey also gave the film a negative rating. She praised Bullock and Kidman as performers but questioned whether the sequel has a strong enough story to justify returning to these characters decades later.
With more reviews still expected, the Rotten Tomatoes score could change. For now, Practical Magic 2 has received mixed reviews and marks a rare low point in Bullock’s recent filmography.
Originally reported on ComingSoon.
