A judicial nominee put forward by Donald Trump declined this week to state plainly whether the Constitution prevents the president from seeking another four years in office, turning a routine confirmation hearing into a debate over the meaning of presidential term limits.
James P. Sullivan questioned by Sen. Chris Coons about presidential term limits
Texas Supreme Court Justice James P. Sullivan, whom Donald Trump selected for a federal district judgeship in West Texas, faced questioning from Delaware Sen. Chris Coons during a Senate Judiciary Committee hearing Wednesday. Coons asked Sullivan to describe what the Twenty-Second Amendment says.
Sullivan faltered. He said he carries the amendment “over my heart because sometimes it isn’t in my brain,” then paused and muttered, “Oh boy, oh boy.” Coons supplied the opening line, and Sullivan completed the thought: “No person shall be elected more than twice, I believe, to the office of the president.” The senator then asked whether the president has won and served two terms. Sullivan confirmed that Trump “has been certified as the winner in the 2016 and the 2024” elections. When Coons asked point-blank whether Trump may run again in 2028, Sullivan sidestepped.
He cited Canon 5 of the American Bar Association’s Code of Judicial Conduct, which sets restrictions on political activity by judges and judicial candidates, and said answering would violate it. He also called the matter “a subject of ongoing political debate.” Coons rejected that framing. “That’s a very disappointing answer,” he said, calling the amendment “bracingly clear on the face of it.” He added that the third term question “is only unresolved in the mind of President Trump.”
The president has flirted publicly with a third term. He told NBC News in March 2025 that he was “not joking” about the idea, and he told Time magazine in April that “there are some loopholes that have been discussed that are well known.” No such loopholes exist under the amendment’s text. All in all, Sullivan joined the Texas Supreme Court in January 2025 after Governor Greg Abbott appointed him. He now awaits a confirmation vote for the Western District of Texas seat.
