Donald Trump’s Fight With Iowa Pollster Hits Major Legal Roadblock
Photo by Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images

Donald Trump’s Fight With Iowa Pollster Hits Major Legal Roadblock

An Iowa judge dismissed Donald Trump’s lawsuit against the Des Moines Register and pollster J. Ann Selzer on Wednesday. The judge ruled that a pre-election poll showing the Republican trailing was protected speech under the First Amendment.

Donald Trump’s lawsuit over the Des Moines Register poll is dismissed by judge

Iowa District Judge Scott Beattie threw out the case. He found that Trump’s lawsuit attempted to stretch state law beyond its limits by converting constitutionally protected speech into fraud. “Ratings, forecasts, and predictions that reflect a subjective weighing of objective data ⁠points are not sufficiently factual to be susceptible to proof, and predicting uncertain future events is not ​an exact science for which a publisher may be held to account,” Beattie wrote (via Reuters)

Moreover, the judge ruled that the First Amendment barred the lawsuit and that the claims did not fit Iowa’s fraud statutes. Donald Trump sued the Iowa newspaper, its parent company Gannett, and Selzer in late 2024. The suit centered on a Des Moines Register poll released days before the November election. It showed Democrat Kamala Harris ahead in Iowa.

Trump accused the newspaper and its longtime pollster of misleading readers. Selzer’s final poll proved an outlier; Trump won Iowa comfortably and reclaimed the White House. FIRE, the free speech group that represented Selzer, welcomed the ruling. “We’re pleased that the court recognized what we’ve said all along. This lawsuit was laughable from the beginning and never should have been brought,” FIRE chief counsel said in a statement.

Additionally, a spokesman for Trump’s personal legal team said the president would appeal. He claimed the Register and Gannett knowingly published a “phony poll” in an “unlawful attempt to interfere in the 2024 presidential election and to defraud Americans into believing” Harris was winning.

All in all, the ruling is a clear win for press freedom advocates who argued the lawsuit threatened to weaponize courts against political polling.

TRENDING

X