Willow Smith Gets Mixed Response After Covering Amerie Classic
Photo by PG/Bauer-Griffin/GC Images

Willow Smith Gets Mixed Response After Covering Amerie Classic

Willow Smith gets mixed reactions after covering Amerie Rogers’s iconic hit 1 Thing during her appearance on BBC Radio 1. While some online users praised her talent, others criticized her for choosing the song.

Willow Smith covered “1 Thing” for BBC Radio

Willow Smith appeared on BBC Radio 1 Live Lounge on November 17, where she performed Amerie’s signature 2005 R&B hit 1 Thing. Soon after the stream, her performance received mixed reactions from the audience. The performance quickly gained attention, and listeners continued to share clips of her performance.

Many users loved her performance; one user wrote, “Y’all don’t know ball. This smoked this.”

Another user said, “No autotune or backing tracks/vocals, so she gets my respect for this. She’s still super talented & highly underrated musically.”

One user said, “Maybe a different song choice, but for such a difficult song she’s doing fine, and I think the rawness is a part of her style.”

While some users criticised her performance on social media. One X user wrote, “I think everyone should just stop singing this song.”  Another user commented, “terrible by any standard (oh, except the delusionals’).”

One user said, “Anybody that says they like it, or it’s good, should never have an opinion on music. Just listen to what you wanna listen to and don’t ever give your thoughts on anything musical ever. You got whatever Willow got to make her do this.”

Along with 1 Thing, she also performed Unconditional from her July 2026 album The Thread and a new song, Circles.

1 Thing was written by Amerie, Rich Harrison, and Stanley Walden, and produced by Rich Harrison. The iconic song is part of her second Studio album and built around the sample of The Meters’ “Oh, Calcutta!” (via Billboard)

Previously, Willow made headlines for her reply to a stranger who was trying to flirt with her.

Willow’s performance of the song immediately went viral on social media; however, she or Amerie has not publicly addressed the backlash.  The discussion surrounding the cover drew renewed attention to Amerie’s iconic song, which remains popular for its unique production.

TRENDING

X