Sam Hartman’s Bachelor Nation debut arrived with an awkward reminder of his romantic past. Hours after ABC announced him as the lead for Season 30, a woman claiming to be his former partner described their relationship as toxic.
Becca Hunt’s comments added an unexpected twist to his search for love. She also claimed she had interviewed for the same season, raising the possibility of an uncomfortable on-camera reunion.
Becca Hunt describes toxic relationship with Sam Hartman

Hunt shared a photo with Hartman on TikTok alongside a pointed caption. “The most toxic relationship in my life is now the bachelor LOL,” she wrote. The post quickly attracted questions about their alleged history, but Hunt declined to share further details.
“Look, y’all, I am not going to say anything more [about] this; I just thought it was ironic because it’s a dating show,” she explained in the comments. She later clarified that her remark did not place all the blame on Hartman. “also, saying it was the most toxic relationship of my life is not putting all the blame on him. Just ironic he’s now on a dating show. Hope this helps!” she added. Hunt also revealed another surprising detail: “what’s funny is i was interviewed to be on this season.”
ABC announced Hartman as its new Bachelor on November 13, 2026. The 27-year-old Washington Commanders quarterback discussed the casting during an appearance on Good Morning America. He admitted that reality television’s stigma initially made him hesitant. A conversation with host Jesse Palmer, who also played in the NFL before becoming the Bachelor in 2004, helped change his mind.
Hartman joked that talking to 30 women could prove challenging. He sometimes struggled to hold a conversation with just one, he admitted. Still, he had a clear idea of what he wanted. “somebody that I want to be able to chase… in a way that they have a drive for something and that motivates me to wake up every day and chase them,” he said on the show.
Hartman joined Washington as an undrafted free agent in 2024 and is currently on the Commanders’ practice squad. He has yet to play in an NFL regular-season game. Reports also linked him to soccer player Tyla Ochoa, with their apparent split reportedly occurring in early 2025. Neither has publicly confirmed the breakup.
