A federal appeals court handed Pete Hegseth another legal loss on Tuesday, refusing to let his Defense Department dismiss more than two dozen transgender service members while the Supreme Court decides whether to take up the case. The ruling keeps roughly 27 active-duty troops in uniform for now and expands the legal fight over the Pentagon’s policy.
Federal appeals court denies Pentagon’s request to proceed with dismissals
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit rejected the Pentagon’s request to enforce its policy targeting transgender service members while its appeal proceeds. The court had previously ruled in June that the policy was motivated by a desire to harm transgender people. Despite that ruling, Pete Hegseth’s department sought permission to implement the policy as the Supreme Court considers whether to take up the case.
Judge Robert Wilkins, appointed by Barack Obama, wrote in Tuesday’s filing that the government offered no substantial reason to carry out the policy in the meantime. “The government has not alleged any irreparable harm that will result from retention of the currently serving Plaintiffs—decorated service members who have ‘served honorably’ while meeting ‘all military standards’ during their service,” Wilkins stated.
“Instead of contesting these facts, the government generically asserts that our mandate requires the military to implement a policy that it believes poses ‘substantial risks’ to an effective national defense.”
Judge Judith Rogers, a Bill Clinton appointee, joined Wilkins in denying the request. Judge Justin Walker, appointed by Donald Trump, backed the administration. The Department of Defense has not yet commented. The ruling shields about 27 active-duty service members (via Military.com).
The case traces back to Trump’s January 2025 executive order, which claimed transgender service members’ sexual identity “conflicts with a soldier’s commitment to an honorable, truthful, and disciplined lifestyle, even in one’s personal life.” Pete Hegseth followed with a policy that presumptively disqualified people with gender dysphoria from serving.
