Madden’s RT Score Sets New Low for Christian Bale, Here’s Why Critics Hate the Movie
Photo Credit: Chuck Zlotnick/Prime

Madden’s RT Score Sets New Low for Christian Bale, Here’s Why Critics Hate the Movie

Reviews of Nicolas Cage’s Madden biopic are in, and they have set a new record for Christian Bale’s filmography. With critics mostly negative, Madden has become Bale’s lowest-rated film of his nearly 40-year career. At the time of writing, Madden sits at a measly 15% on Rotten Tomatoes.

The film follows John Madden, the legendary NFL coach, as he moves from the field to becoming the face of the successful video game franchise. The film also explores his relationship with Al Davis and tracks their partnership as they lead the Raiders to a Super Bowl XI victory.

Critics have blasted Cage’s performance, pointing to the film’s inconsistent tone and lack of focus. “If ‘Madden’ were a football game, it would be an offensively challenged contest, filled with turnovers and penalties, the kind of performance that could get coaches fired,” reads an excerpt from the San Francisco Chronicle.

The criticism of Madden goes beyond its Rotten Tomatoes score

Some reviews also point to Cage’s performance as a caricature of the coach. It also appears to suffer from indecisiveness about what kind of story it wants to tell.

“David O. Russell’s penchant for broad comedy eventually crowds out his humanistic side,” reads Slant Magazine’s review. Similarly, Screen Daily’s review also speaks of director David O. Russel’s insincere approach to telling Madden’s story. “Although the film covers fertile terrain, Russell’s glib approach quickly irritates as there’s nothing beneath the superficial flashiness,” reads an excerpt from their review.

Besides Bale and Cage, Madden also stars Kathryn Hahn, Sienna Miller, Simms May, John Mulaney, and Shane Gillis. Russel directs from a script he and Cambron Clark wrote. Madden is produced by Todd Black, Jason Blumenthal, Steve Tisch, and Russell, alongside NFL Films and Skydance Sports.

Madden is playing in select theaters and will stream on Prime Video from November 18, 2026.

Originally reported on ComingSoon.

TRENDING

X