Cristin Milioti’s low-budget horror comedy is doing something almost unheard of at the box office right now. The film defied expectations with a rare second-weekend increase and has turned its modest budget into a massive return.
Cristin Milioti’s Buddy proves to be really profitable at box office
Cristin Milioti’s horror comedy Buddy continues to deliver strong returns at the box office. The film has grossed $21,183,527 domestically against a production budget of just $3 million, according to Box Office Mojo. Roadside Attractions and Saban Films distributed the R-rated feature, which opened on August 28, 2026.
Buddy earned $5,464,870 during its opening weekend across 1,277 theaters. The film averaged $4,279 per theater in that first frame. Director Casper Kelly’s feature then defied typical second-weekend drops with an unusual trajectory.
The film actually gained momentum in its sophomore outing. It expanded to 1,771 theaters and grossed $5,802,653, marking a 6.2% increase over its debut. The Labor Day holiday weekend further boosted its performance to $7,407,935 across that extended frame. The per-theater average settled at $3,276 during the standard weekend count.
Buddy saw a steeper decline in its third weekend. It earned $3,416,279 across 1,720 theaters, dropping 41.1% from the previous frame. The per-theater average fell to $1,986 during that period. The film still held the number six spot on the domestic chart.
The horror comedy follows a group of children trapped inside a surreal 1990s-style children’s television series. Keegan-Michael Key voices the titular antagonist alongside a cast featuring Delaney Quinn, Patton Oswalt, Michael Shannon, and Topher Grace. Kelly developed the concept after producers approached him to create a horror film inspired by Barney & Friends.
The independent production shot over 25 days in Northeast Ohio locations including Brooklyn, Solon, and Burton. Buddy premiered at the 2026 Sundance Film Festival before securing its theatrical distribution deal.
